I Wrote Myself a Letter, I Got a Response

Creep Cast Season 1 Episode 51

Overview:
Isaiah and Hunter read a story where a 25-year-old man named Scott writes a letter to himself. He receives a physical reply, but things escalate into a dark, disturbing psychological and supernatural trap involving twisted realities and desperate choices.

Author: Verastahl

Genre : Mystery, Sci-Fi & Fantasy, Comedy

Actors : Hunter Hancock, Isaiah Mark Nichols

Release Date : 2025-04-06

Duration : 133 menit

Rating : ⭐ 0/10 (0 votes)

▶ Play

Select Season

Other Episodes (Season 1)

The Stairs in the Woods
1. The Stairs in the Woods
Jeff the Killer
2. Jeff the Killer
The Russian Sleep Experiment
3. The Russian Sleep Experiment
Borrasca Pt. 1
4. Borrasca Pt. 1
Borrasca Pt. 2
5. Borrasca Pt. 2
My Dead Girlfriend Keeps Messaging Me on Facebook
6. My Dead Girlfriend Keeps Messaging Me on Facebook
Penpal
7. Penpal
Left Right Game Pt. 1
8. Left Right Game Pt. 1
Left Right Game Pt. 2
9. Left Right Game Pt. 2
Gr3gory88
10. Gr3gory88
The Thing in the Basement is Getting Better at Mimicking People
11. The Thing in the Basement is Getting Better at Mimicking People
1999
12. 1999
The Showers
13. The Showers
NoEnd House
14. NoEnd House
Creepy Grab Bag 1
15. Creepy Grab Bag 1
Tommy Taffy
16. Tommy Taffy
GREYLOCK
17. GREYLOCK
My Wife’s Been Peeking at Me from Around Corners
18. My Wife’s Been Peeking at Me from Around Corners
USERNAME 666
19. USERNAME 666
Psychosis
20. Psychosis
Midwest Angelica
21. Midwest Angelica
Feed the Pig
22. Feed the Pig
Creepy Grab Bag 2
23. Creepy Grab Bag 2
Stolen Tongues
24. Stolen Tongues
UrbanSPOOK
25. UrbanSPOOK
It Breathes, It Bleeds, It Breeds
26. It Breathes, It Bleeds, It Breeds
My Job is Watching a Woman Trapped in a Room
27. My Job is Watching a Woman Trapped in a Room
Marble Hornets Pt. 1
28. Marble Hornets Pt. 1
Tales from the Gas Station
29. Tales from the Gas Station
Marble Hornets Pt. 2
30. Marble Hornets Pt. 2
My Husband has Taken Our Roleplaying Too Far
31. My Husband has Taken Our Roleplaying Too Far
My Dog was Missing for Three Days.
32. My Dog was Missing for Three Days.
Deepwoods
33. Deepwoods
SCP 3000
34. SCP 3000
Ted the Caver
35. Ted the Caver
The Whistler at 3:03 AM
36. The Whistler at 3:03 AM
Goatman, Laughing Jack and more

37. Goatman, Laughing Jack and more

The Dionaea House
38. The Dionaea House
If You’re Armed at the Glendmont Metro, Please Shoot Me
39. If You’re Armed at the Glendmont Metro, Please Shoot Me
The Only Other Astronaut on this Mission Died Six Weeks Ago
40. The Only Other Astronaut on this Mission Died Six Weeks Ago
Berries in the Window
41. Berries in the Window
I Dared my Best Friend to Ruin my Life
42. I Dared my Best Friend to Ruin my Life
I’m Blind, I’m Not Sure How Many Steps my Staircase has.
43. I’m Blind, I’m Not Sure How Many Steps my Staircase has.
The Pigeons Around Here aren’t Real
44. The Pigeons Around Here aren’t Real
The Hidden Webpage
45. The Hidden Webpage
My Crew and I are Stuck Aboard an Abandoned Ship
46. My Crew and I are Stuck Aboard an Abandoned Ship
Azalea’s Cookhouse
47. Azalea’s Cookhouse
Creepypasta Classics: The Rake, Candle Cove, Mr. Widemouth
48. Creepypasta Classics: The Rake, Candle Cove, Mr. Widemouth
Dagon’s Mirror
49. Dagon’s Mirror
I Pretended to be a Missing Girl
50. I Pretended to be a Missing Girl
I Wrote Myself a Letter, I Got a Response
51. I Wrote Myself a Letter, I Got a Response
The Red Tower
52. The Red Tower
Burgrr Entries
53. Burgrr Entries
Spire in the Woods
54. Spire in the Woods
Ticci Toby
55. Ticci Toby
Greywater
56. Greywater
Borrasca V
57. Borrasca V
The Sun Vanished
58. The Sun Vanished
Camp Oakwood
59. Camp Oakwood
Ensorcelled in the Earth
60. Ensorcelled in the Earth
My Sugar Daddy Asks Me For Weird Favors
61. My Sugar Daddy Asks Me For Weird Favors
I Work At A Half-Priced Voodoo Shop
62. I Work At A Half-Priced Voodoo Shop
Mother Horse Eyes
63. Mother Horse Eyes
We Weren't Allowed To Talk To Women
64. We Weren't Allowed To Talk To Women
It Came from a Fan...
65. It Came from a Fan...
Fleshgait
66. Fleshgait
The Church in the Woods
67. The Church in the Woods
The Ocean is much Deeper than we Thought
68. The Ocean is much Deeper than we Thought
I Clean Hoarder Houses for a Living
69. I Clean Hoarder Houses for a Living
My Little Pony Creepypasta...
70. My Little Pony Creepypasta...
The Dead Girl in my Yard
71. The Dead Girl in my Yard
Polyamorous Hell
72. Polyamorous Hell
The Flight Attendants won’t Stop Crying
73. The Flight Attendants won’t Stop Crying
The Bloodridge Motel
74. The Bloodridge Motel
I Talked to God
75. I Talked to God
There's Something Wrong With Wendigoon
76. There's Something Wrong With Wendigoon
Smile Dog
77. Smile Dog
Accounts From A Lonely Broadcast
78. Accounts From A Lonely Broadcast
Room 733
79. Room 733
The Whistlers
80. The Whistlers
Journal of an Unknown Soldier
81. Journal of an Unknown Soldier
Smiling Ones On Space Station Mir
82. Smiling Ones On Space Station Mir
My Dad Ate Meat From A Deer That Walked On Two Legs
83. My Dad Ate Meat From A Deer That Walked On Two Legs
The Bearded Man In My Window
84. The Bearded Man In My Window
Dogscape
85. Dogscape
Dreams Beneath The Witch Tree
86. Dreams Beneath The Witch Tree
Stairs In The Woods
87. Stairs In The Woods
Jane The Killer
88. Jane The Killer
Drumming In The Clouds
89. Drumming In The Clouds
Marble Hornets Pt. 3
90. Marble Hornets Pt. 3
TURN IT OFF
91. TURN IT OFF
I Found The Bunker Of A Prepper Family
92. I Found The Bunker Of A Prepper Family
The Harbinger Experiment
93. The Harbinger Experiment
Something’s Strange About My Neighbor
94. Something’s Strange About My Neighbor
Happy Appy
95. Happy Appy
Rat King
96. Rat King
Ronald McDonald House
97. Ronald McDonald House
HELP. I'm Trapped in a Sitcom
98. HELP. I'm Trapped in a Sitcom
The Delaurier Invitation
99. The Delaurier Invitation
The Scariest Japanese Creepy Pastas
100. The Scariest Japanese Creepy Pastas
Necrosleep
101. Necrosleep
Whitefall
102. Whitefall
Lucille's Late Night Snack Bar
103. Lucille's Late Night Snack Bar
The Puppet In The Tree
104. The Puppet In The Tree
Confessions Of A Deep Sea Diver
105. Confessions Of A Deep Sea Diver
I Was An Air Traffic Controller
106. I Was An Air Traffic Controller
Ad Nauseam
107. Ad Nauseam
The Animals on my Farm Kill their Newborns
108. The Animals on my Farm Kill their Newborns
Point Pine Series
109. Point Pine Series
The Slenderman Stabbing
110. The Slenderman Stabbing
The Living History Project
111. The Living History Project
The Forest of A Thousand Legs
112. The Forest of A Thousand Legs
My Property Isn't Normal
113. My Property Isn't Normal
The Moon Is On Fire
114. The Moon Is On Fire
My Dad Took Us Camping
115. My Dad Took Us Camping
Gemini Home Entertainment
116. Gemini Home Entertainment
The Man In My Basement Takes One Step Closer
117. The Man In My Basement Takes One Step Closer
I Explored An Abandoned White Supremacist Camp
118. I Explored An Abandoned White Supremacist Camp
I Got Hired at a Modeling Agency
119. I Got Hired at a Modeling Agency
The Sandman
120. The Sandman
I Solved The Fermi Paradox
121. I Solved The Fermi Paradox
The Axe-Wielder
122. The Axe-Wielder
Incel Horror Story
123. Incel Horror Story
Jeff The Killer vs. Slenderman
124. Jeff The Killer vs. Slenderman
We Used To Live Here
125. We Used To Live Here
I Work For A Private Museum
126. I Work For A Private Museum
Waffle House Horror
127. Waffle House Horror
The Antichrist Salesman
128. The Antichrist Salesman
The Lurker on the Stairway
129. The Lurker on the Stairway
Where the Caterpillars Die
130. Where the Caterpillars Die

TV Series Recommendations

Creeped Out
Goosebumps
Maggie
Over the Garden Wall
The Birch
Freddy's Nightmares
The Mighty Boosh
The Rook
Eerie, Indiana
So Weird
Creepshow
Now Apocalypse
The Spooktacular New Adventures of Casper
Are You Afraid of the Dark?
Home Movie: The Princess Bride
The Institute
Be Cool, Scooby-Doo!
Tripping the Rift